Map projections
An orange peel cannot be laid flat without tearing or stretching, and the Earth's surface is no different. Every map is a compromise; the only question is which property is sacrificed and where the distortion stays small enough.
Why every map distorts
Gauss proved in 1827 that a curved surface cannot be mapped into a plane without distortion. Every projection must therefore decide what to preserve, and no projection can preserve all three of the following at once.
| Property | Meaning | Example | Good for |
|---|---|---|---|
| conformal | angles and small shapes are preserved | Mercator, UTM, Gauss-Krüger | navigation, surveying, topographic maps |
| equal area | area ratios are preserved | Mollweide, Albers | thematic world maps, statistics |
| equidistant | distances are correct, but only along particular lines | azimuthal equidistant | radio range, routes from one point |
For anything involving GPS, conformality is the decisive property: a bearing taken from the map must match the bearing in the field. All common navigation maps are therefore conformal, and all of them pay with distortion of area and distance that grows with the distance from where the projection touches the globe.
Mercator: conformal but not true to scale
Gerardus Mercator presented a world map in 1569 on which any line of constant compass course is straight. For seafarers that was revolutionary. The price is a stretching that grows without limit towards the poles.
| Latitude | Lengths enlarged | Areas enlarged |
|---|---|---|
| 0° | 1.00 × | 1.00 × |
| 30° | 1.15 × | 1.33 × |
| 50° | 1.56 × | 2.42 × |
| 60° | 2.00 × | 4.00 × |
| 70° | 2.92 × | 8.55 × |
| 78° | 4.81 × | 23.1 × |
Hence the familiar result: Greenland looks about as large as Africa, which actually has fourteen times the area. Because nearly every online map service uses a Mercator variant, that distortion still shapes how people picture the world. For navigation over a few kilometres it is harmless, since the factor barely changes across one map view.
Web Mercator, the projection of online maps, computes on a sphere rather than an ellipsoid for simplicity. For viewing that makes no difference. Measuring areas or distances on it in Central Europe gives values more than half again too large, because the factor from the table applies in full.
The trick: turn the cylinder
Mercator wraps a cylinder around the equator, where the map is true to scale and from where distortion grows north and south. Turn the cylinder by 90 degrees and it touches along a meridian instead: the map is then true to scale along that meridian and distortion grows east and west. Restrict it to a narrow strip either side and the distortion stays so small that the map can be treated as a flat sheet, with distances in metres and coordinates combined by Pythagoras. Both UTM and Gauss-Krüger are built on this.
UTM: the world in 60 strips
UTM divides the Earth into 60 zones of six degrees of longitude, numbered eastward from 180° West. Germany falls into zones 32 and 33, divided at the 12th meridian.
To spread the distortion more evenly, the scale on the central meridian is not 1 but 0.9996, so the map there is 40 centimetres per kilometre too small. About 180 kilometres from the central meridian the scale is exactly true, and beyond that it becomes too large. At 50 degrees latitude a zone is roughly 430 kilometres wide and the error at its edge is about 17 centimetres per kilometre; at the equator the zone is 668 kilometres wide and the edge reaches almost one metre per kilometre.
| Component | Example, Munich | Meaning |
|---|---|---|
| Zone | 32 | strip from 6° to 12° East, central meridian 9° East |
| Latitude band | U | band from 48° to 56° North, for orientation only |
| Easting | 691,435 m | 500,000 m at the central meridian, so Munich is 191 km east of it |
| Northing | 5,334,908 m | distance from the equator in metres, measured in the projection |
The easting starts at 500,000 rather than zero so that no negative values occur; in the southern hemisphere the northing starts at 10,000,000 for the same reason. Conversion between latitude, longitude and UTM is built into the converter under Latitude and longitude.
On topographic maps the UTM grid is usually printed as kilometre squares, and a position is read off by taking the easting first and the northing second, estimating the metres within the square. That is faster and less error prone than converting from latitude and longitude, which is why mountain rescue, fire services and the military work in UTM.
Gauss-Krüger, the German predecessor
Until the 2010s official surveying in Germany used Gauss-Krüger: the same projection, but with strips three degrees wide, a scale of exactly 1 on the central meridian, and the Bessel ellipsoid in the Potsdam datum. The first digit of the easting identifies the strip: 2 for the central meridian at 6° East, 3 for 9°, 4 for 12° and 5 for 15°.
For the same point in Munich, Gauss-Krüger gives easting 4,468,350 and northing 5,333,485, while UTM gives 691,435 and 5,334,908. The northings differ by 1.4 kilometres for three reasons at once: the point sits at a different distance from the central meridian, the scale factor of 0.9996 removes about two kilometres, and the smaller Bessel ellipsoid shifts the remainder. Old maps with a Gauss-Krüger grid and a receiver set to UTM therefore produce numbers that cannot be compared at all.